book-reviews, books

Beyond the border – India China Boundary Issues

India China Boundry Issues - Book by Ranjait Singh
India China Boundry Issues - Book by Ranjait Singh Kalha
The personal and professional experience of Ranjit Singh Kalha, who has dealt with China for over 12 years, makes his book refreshingly different from many others on the boundary issue ALTHOUGH there are many books on the complex issue of the unsettled boundary between India and China, Ambassador Ranjit Singh Kalha’s book is a welcome addition. Broadly, there are two schools of thought among scholars studying China. The first one worships China with such devotion that we need to coin a new word, sinolatry, along the lines of idolatry, to describe it. Examples of two books in this school readily come to mind. One is When China Rules the World: The End of the Western World Order and the Birth of a New Global Order by Martin Jacques, which came out in 2009. The other is Eclipse: Living under China’s Economic Dominance by Arvind Subramanian, who was recently appointed Chief Economic Adviser to the Government of India. The second school, much less prolific and much less influential, propagates a sort of sinophobia, basically a mixture of hatred and fear of China. Kalha, neither sinolatrous nor sinophobic, is sober and scientific, and he writes with remarkable lucidity. Kalha’s compulsory foreign language when he joined the Indian Foreign Service in 1965 was Chinese. In 1972, he was posted to China. He went to China via Hong Kong, and on the train in the mainland he asked for bacon as breakfast was being served. He was refused because some official had decided that the passenger was a Muslim and hence should not be served bacon. Kalha’s showing his passport and declaring his Sikh identity did not change the decision. It is the personal and professional experience of the author, who has dealt with China for over 12 years, including three years of boundary negotiations, that makes this book refreshingly different from others. (more…)

January 10th, 2015 | category:book-reviews, books |

Latest Articles

‘They should have asked students to get out of Ukraine weeks ago’

International Affairs: Articles March 08th, 2022

The Ukraine Crisis & Operation Ganga

International Affairs: Articles March 05th, 2022

A Tale of Two Speeches

Domestic affairs, Politics January 27th, 2022

How China Outsmarted The U.S. At The World Health Assembly

International Affairs: Articles, Politics May 26th, 2020

Fare will put evacuees in a tough spot

International Affairs: Articles May 15th, 2020